after the success of jill paton walsh with harriet and peter i thought one might just try breaking that rule of never -- really really just don't try to -- even touch sequels by anyone other than original authors. and helen cresswell, with her bagthorpes, seemed perfect for continuing the story of that huge squabbling family and their adventures with the irritable psammead. well, no. too obsessed with time travel, is that woman. over sentimental twaddle, a lot of it. and awful pictures. don't bother really
Saturday, July 31, 2004
moondial, helen cresswell
now what i feel about this helen cresswell is -- delightful with the bagthorpes. not so hot with young kiddy books. and with this delicate story -- completely wrong. her style of writing can't seem to sustain the pensive languid charm necessary to her really rather well-conceived time travel plot, and therefore it annoys because it can't satisfy. why are bagthorpes all in woodlands?
a stitch in time, penelope lively
a wistful tale gracefully told, skirting the always rather clumsy device of time travel by only hinting at it at the edges of the story.
Tuesday, July 27, 2004
king of shadows, susan cooper
wow. wow, truly; what i said when i tore my way to the last page and put the book down. the premise, of a talented boy actor translated to shakespeare's london and playing puck to shakespeare's oberon, sounds dodgy, but she handles it with such tenderness and delicacy that the weaknesses -- there are some weaknesses -- lose themselves as she pulls you into the force of the story. really rather beautiful; please do read it the next time you feel in need of some comfort.
Sunday, July 25, 2004
Saturday, July 24, 2004
dogsbody, diana wynne jones
it won't be one of my favourites, but i rather think it is one of her best
the real plato jones, nina bawden
quite a moving account of plato's search for identity; in part, though, what i felt about sport applies. less so, but it does
sport, louise fitzhugh
it was enjoyable, but the thing is she didn't need an established character, from another book, for the plot? as in, any boy would have done as well; one wishes she could have dreamed up something less spectacular, more in keeping with character, for harriet's best friend
Wednesday, July 21, 2004
carrie's war, nina bawden
inordinately pleased with this. it isn't that often books with good reputations live up to them, but this held me right through to the end
Tuesday, July 20, 2004
Monday, July 19, 2004
the documents in the case, dorothy l. sayers
i maintain that detectiveless detective stories are rather trying. and i think dorothy sayers' mysteries are entirely too clever and too scientific and too too technical for anything!
power of three, diana wynne jones
actually a quite sophisticated piece of fairy tale on its head writing. cool.
the merlin conspiracy, diana wynne jones
her imagination is so effervescent and her plots so involved that i always find her books repay a second reading. i get it better, the second time. maybe i'm just really stupid; these are yp books are they not? ah well.
absolute zero, helen cresswell
i think it is a mark of her skill that i want to slap one or another of the bagthorpes most of the time. yay.
Tuesday, July 13, 2004
the temple of dawn, yukio mishima
without the central figure of an impassioned young japanese boy living in that white flame of passion -- as in the two earlier -- this made for much swifter, shallower reading, i thought. or perhaps it was the atmosphere in which i read it -- the teacher's room; relieving a (sec four n(a)) class; on the train from school to orchard. however i was touched by the portrait of ageing honda and his sudden steadfast unbelievable love. one awaits the resolution of the tetralogy with pleasure, perhaps the best kind, which feels certain of satisfaction
bagthorpes unlimited, helen cresswell
minzhi was right -- 'big family, v your thing', as i recall she said. exactly my thing. bring them on
Sunday, July 11, 2004
a presumption of death, jill paton walsh
almost i think she should write more ... not maybe quite as ingenious, but i like more harriet in the books, and peter seems to have toned down in old age :)
gemma in love, noel streatfeild
was always ashamed to be seen taking out a book of this title, but ah well. it's good!
Friday, July 09, 2004
the white mercedes, philip pullman
bleak, tragic, with the driving inevitability of some chilling play.
the sittaford mystery, agatha christie
ooh. clever. but without a detective the solution presentation becomes a little weak
runaway horses, yukio mishima
immense loyalty, dedication, courage, love. without the measured ceremony of the first but just as impassioned, just as fanatical, cold and single-minded as the blade that figures so much in the tale. he's kind of well, fanatical, isn't he? but still. is honda going to be chasing kiyoaki's reincarnations through the quartet?
Wednesday, July 07, 2004
mennyms alive, sylvia waugh
often the most touching of the books; the character of daisy and how she treats the mennyms was a brilliant stroke. i wish, though, someone would explain the names; i was hoping aunt kate would :( magnus, tulip, joshua, vinetta -- okay; soobie, pilbeam, appleby -- strange but you know, acceptably so; poopie, wimpey, googles -- almost rude, no? ah well.
mennyms alone, sylvia waugh
my heart nearly stopped when the door opened again, and when i read the last page i was very very very glad the next book was immediately to hand!
when marnie was there, joan g. robinson
the blurb said it was the best of its genre since tom's midnight garden, which i thought was annoyingly too much of a giveaway. the story is quite beautiful in parts, and the little girl protagonist very sympathetic, but the end is a little too neat. another accidental find
fire and hemlock, diana wynne jones
i'd read this before, but i liked it a lot better this time. after all these fantasy writers go on about it so i should find about tam lin shouldn't i?
Friday, July 02, 2004
when hitler stole pink rabbit, judith kerr
written with a great deal of courage and humour
and -- pink rabbit does not actually feature in this story, on account of having been stolen :)
and -- pink rabbit does not actually feature in this story, on account of having been stolen :)
Thursday, July 01, 2004
the witch's daughter, nina bawden
about -- finding your own power? i like the way she handles three or more quite major characters, and has them interact and grow and you know, aid in the finding-self-and-wisdom-in-self of each other
momo, michael ende
a beautiful fairy story ... which means, a rather obvious fable like lesson :) but some very well drawn characters (not momo though, not really my type of thing) not excluding a very special tortoise called cassiopiea! i think i spelt that right ...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)